Brokeback
December 27th, 2005 by brianschwartzFirst off, I would like to thank Kate for her sweet comment to my first post which I just now read.
This entry, however muddled and muddy, will be about Brokeback Mountain so if you haven’t seen it, you might not want to read on. I won’t give away any major "surprises" though.
So for some reason, this film never sucked me in. I was very aware of their acting, of Heath Ledger’s accent…I just couldn’t connect how I wanted to. The love between them was great, sudden, but great. Here’s my problem: Why is it still okay to make movies where women are just pawns on which to inflict pain? Why are we supposed to relate and root for men who resent women. Maybe the resentment wasn’t gendered in this case, but the women were still treated really poorly throughout. Why did the women fall for HL’s character? Cuz he was hot? Cuz he was quiet? Cuz he was occassionally sweet? Cuz, as Jake’s character attested, he barely spoke, so when he did…you couldn’t help fall for him??
It just didn’t make sense, or the problem is, it did. We’re so ingrained to men who can’t express themselves, who suffer silently, that when they treat women like their an affliction to the earth we don’t even notice? Or if we do, we’re forgiving? Maybe I don’t get it cuz I am a man?
I think I need to read Annie Proulx’s short story. Is it just that we all know the story of the conflicted man? That that story crosses genders and maybe even crosses cultures?? because it’s so familiar? I hope not. I hope manhood will not be defined as a man dealing with maintaining structure that fights pleasure and fighting pleasure that’s societally restricted.
After my last posting I wanted to write a sweet Christmas suite, detailing the multicolored nights, briefly welcomed night brisk air, the buzz of familyer voices, and food food food food. But let’s just say that all that happened, since we know it, and maybe we can savor whatever cheer graced our senses.
The two women I’ve spoken with Brokeback about noticed, or at least focused on, the love story in the fill, not the gender disparities. Maybe it’s just a mail hang up? Maybe I feel guilty about something? Either way, let me know what y’all think.