cri tique cri tic
Friday, February 17th, 2006Lately, my sharper edge–double entendre’d–has let me down. Although I have spent the significant portion of my life honing my taste, “intelligence,” and discernance, my analysis finally f e e l s more counterpro than pro(-ductive). Although many good critiques have a late lining of hope, the negativity of criticality is swamping me. And although I notice, admiringly and disapprovingly, the critiques and criticisms of others, my own criticism, spoken and un, woes me the moest.
The other day I was sitting next to a friend at a talk and they were occasionally giving postive, quiet feedback to the speaker, nodding vigorously, whispering in my ear, and (worst of all) smiling, mouth slightly agape. Although I enjoyed the speaker, founding him amusin, and deeply admired his work, I felt two things most pronouncedly–critical of him, and critical of my friend. For the speaker: Why was he making so many bad jokes? Why was he so self-righteous? Why did he have to implicitly undercut the competitors in his field who were working toward the same goal, but who hadn’t achieved the same success? For the friend: Why couldn’t she just sit still and listen? Who was she talking to when she was giving feedback? Him? Me? Did either of us ask to be talked to?
I wish I could say this was me at my worst…but of course, it’s probably not. (Why did I put that ellipsis there? Do I really need it?) The trouble is I appreciate both of these people immensely. They have a positivity and capability for production I dream of having.
Each time I criticize someone or something these days, I end up regretting it. Even though sometimes people want or need “constructive criticism” or feedback, I often don’t know how to give it well. More often, I send out my critical vibes unsolicited and then bounce back to high jack me.
I don’t think I’m espousing gushing, and if I go the uberpositive route for a while I’ll probably boomering toward ultracriticism, but what is it that people need in life? Do we need to improve? Do we need to feel good? (N)either? Can(’t) both happen at once?